The Cost Of Lubricating Trunk Piston Engines
Over the past 25 years, the specific fuel consumption for marine trunk piston engines has reduced and an increasing number of such engines are designed for residual fuel operation whether they are for main propulsion or auxiliary purposes.
The cost of fuel varies widely as the spot market price of fuel oil fluctuates. Also the cost of lubricant is an expense, which while it is not generally subject to such price variations, may be converted to a fuel equivalent value in order to better understand the running costs of a trunk piston engine.
The reduction in specific fuel consumption has taken place through evolutionary design stages and has been achieved by a general increase in pressure and temperature in the operating cycle, so making greater demands upon the ring pack. The function of the lubricant in such engines is multipurpose, it has to lubricate the cylinder to minimize wear, lubricate the bearings and running gear and cool the underpiston crown. As a result of the first function, debris from the ring pack is transported to the circulating oil and this carbonaceous matter is seen as insolubles. Treatment of the oil is carried out.by periodic makeup, filtration and also often by suitable centrifuging of the charge.
Even after all this, there is sometimes a definite trend for the insolubles burden to continue to increase so that partial or total renewal of the charge is necessary to enable the lubricant to satisfactorily perform the functions defined above. In addition, other trends have taken place which also have an effect upon the lubricant. These are the reduction of the oil charge in some designs, when expressed on a kg/kw basis and also a reduction of the lubricating oil consumption by attention to the ring pack design.
These trends have a significant effect on the oil in circulation with respect to alkalinity reserve, expressed as Total Base Number TBN mgKOH/g, and insoluble burden.
After a period of time the alkalinity reserve will stabilize at a value which is a function of the engine design, sulphur level of the fuel burnt and the oil consumption rate.
The total oil consumption related to oil change interval is shown in Fig. 1. It should be noted that the total consumption is the addition of the make up oil used and the oil used to replenish the charge when expressed on a g/kwh basis. By way of illustration two conditions are shown, condition A, which is for a design charge of 1.2 kg/kw and consumption of 1.3 g/kwh, and condition B, which is for a charge of 0.5 kg/kw and consumption of 0.6 g/ kwh. Experience has shown that for condition A oil changes under normal operating parameters are infrequent and hence the total consump- tion can be approximated to that of the make up consumption. While for condition B, oil changes are required.
The lubricating oil used, being a consumable item, can be related to fuel and this associated cost or penalty can be determined from Fig. 2 or Fig. 3, depending on whether the engine has a high or low consumption.
Usually marine lubricating oil is purchased under term contract and hence is not subject to severe price fluctuations, its price being determined by the component cost and market forces. On the other hand, fuel oil is purchased on the spot market and is subject to wide price variation. In this decade the fuel price has fluctuated in the range of $35-$220/ton. Such a variation has a significant effect on the lubricating oil fuel equivalent penalty (LOFEP) for trunk piston engines.
Determination of LOFEP is illustrated by the plotted example in Fig. 2 where the following values have been used: Total oil consumption 1.5 g/kwh; lubricating oil price, $l,600/ton; and fuel price, $90/ton.
Using these values, the procedure for determining LOFEP from Fig. 2 is as follows: (1) construct a vertical line representing 1.5 g/kwh to intersect the lubricating oil price ($l,600/ton); (2) from this intersection, construct a horizontal line to intersect the fuel price line ($90/ ton); drop a vertical line to the horizontal axis to determine LOFEP.
In Fig. 3 which is for a low consumption condition the procedure is similar to that for Fig. 2. This is illustrated with the values 0/625 g/ kwh, lubricating oil price $1,600/ ton, fuel price, $90/ton, and a cost factor of 1.0. This procedure is identical for the first two steps as described for Fig. 2. At the third step the vertical line is taken to the intersection of the cost factor line (in this case 1.0). Then from this intersection construct a horiziontal line to the vertical axis for determining the LOFEP under the plotted conditions.
The factor line, third quadrant (bottom left) in Fig. 3, allows the cost of alternative lubricants to be examined. This may be due to a change in cost because of a variation in TBN or consideration of another lubricant. The LOFEP value obtained, whether it be from Fig. 2 or Fig. 3, should be added to the specific fuel consumption in order to take account in fuel terms the effect of a particular lubrication regime.
For further information on marine lubricant products from BP Marine, Circle 96 on Reader Service Card
Other stories from October 1989 issue
- HydroComp Offers New Ship Propulsion Design Software page: 6
- Rockwool Panel Systems Installed Aboard Fantasy —Literature Available page: 6
- Electrode Products Now Markets Full Range Of Metal-Coated Electrodes —Literature Available page: 8
- Seaworthy Systems Opens West Coast Branch Office In San Francisco Bay Area page: 8
- JJH Establishes Small Boat Engineering Department— J. Koelbel Named Director page: 9
- HHI Constructing Specialized RO/RO For United Baltic Corp. page: 9
- Astilleros Espanoles Delivers First Of Four Del Monte Reefers page: 11
- FISH EXPO '89 October 18-21, Seattle, Washington page: 12
- The Cost Of Lubricating Trunk Piston Engines page: 16
- IMODCO To Provide Petrobras With World's Deepest CALM Terminals page: 17
- EURO PORTt '89 page: 18
- Wartsila Diesel's Vasa 32 Sets A New Record: Passes The 1,000 Engine Milestone page: 20
- Marotta Scientific Controls Wins Aegis Shipbuilding Excellence Award page: 21
- William IN. Johnston, Former Head Of ABS page: 22
- McDermott Completes Deepest Pipelines In U.S. Waters page: 22
- Magnavox Multi-Channel Satcom For QE 2 page: 23
- Gladsky Marine Offers Large Crane Vessel For Lift Operations page: 24
- Hatch & Kirk Offers New Engine Parts For Older Diesels page: 24
- Gunter Waehling Named Henschel Vice President page: 25
- OSI Affiliated Companies Assume Management Of 2 U.S. Tug/Barge Vessels page: 25
- AT&T Radiotelephone Service Helps You Keep In Touch On The High Seas page: 26
- Jumbo Hopper Barge Launched By Jeffboat Is First Built Since Reopening For Construction page: 27
- COMPETITIVE YUGOSLAV SHIPYARDS AMONG THE WORLD'S LEADERS page: 28
- Consolidated Switchgear Established From Old 'Con-Select' Organization page: 31
- NAPVO Releases Safety Manual page: 32
- October '89/March '90 Liner Rates Announced By Military Sealift Command page: 32
- Renk Tacke Gear Units Chosen By German Navy For New F 123 Frigates page: 33
- $61,4-Million Contract Awarded Maersk Line By Military Sealift Command page: 33
- N e w Labor Agreement At MIL-Davie To Increase Shipyard Efficiency page: 36
- 'Speed Reducers And Your Bottom Line'—A N e w Free Brochure Offered By Falk page: 36
- Cummins-Powered Tender Serves Washington State's New Floating Bridge page: 37
- Lindenau Shipyard Delivers 12,100-DWT Chemical Tanker To West German Owners page: 38
- Third In New Series Of Navigational Satellites Launched Into Orbit page: 39
- Deck Machinery And Cargo-Handling Equipment page: 42
- Wilden Introduces Pumps Designed For Explosive, Hazardous Environments page: 48
- Furuno Introduces New Radar Lines—Opens East Coast Distribution Center page: 49
- Carnival's Newest Superliner, Luxurious 70,000-GRT Fantasy, Nears Completion At Wartsila Yard page: 49
- Halter Delivers Fourth Of Six Navy Ocean Surveillance Ships In Contract Valued At $85 Million page: 52
- $3.4 Million Awarded General Instrument For Spares/Support Equipment page: 53
- New Simple, Easy-To-Use Hydrostatics Program From Concurrent Systems page: 53
- Seatrade's Cruise Shipping '90 Conference & Exhibition Set For March 20-24 In Miami page: 56
- Blount Marine Launches First Dinner/Excursion Boat Of New Ultramodern Design page: 57
- Marco Completes Major Changes In Fishing Vessel 'Sea Wolf' page: 62
- Peterson Builders Realigns Management Staff page: 64